tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post5170380913139918804..comments2023-07-26T21:53:52.878+08:00Comments on SEAN-THE-MAN.blogspot.com: NON MUSLIM TAXES CANNOT BE USED TO BUILD MOSQUES!sean-the-manhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/16015387695941406581noreply@blogger.comBlogger8125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post-29488346301152706782010-01-18T03:12:17.593+08:002010-01-18T03:12:17.593+08:00if non muslim n non bumi should go back to their o...if non muslim n non bumi should go back to their origin country. so do such called malay. they are from indon. read ya sejarah again n again, moronAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post-89313157190964491102010-01-08T18:47:22.410+08:002010-01-08T18:47:22.410+08:00I let those comments stay because the blogpost the...I let those comments stay because the blogpost then becomes like a zoo. You can see the animals for yourself ;)<br /><br />Anyway, one last rebuttal to morky.<br /><br />He asks how I know taxes collected from non-Muslims are used to build mosques.<br /><br />How does he know that it was not?<br /><br />If we believe the govt pools all its revenue sources (of which non-Muslim taxes comprise 50%), and some of that revenue goes into building mosques - then it's simple logic that 50% of the money that goes into mosques are of non-Muslim origin.<br /><br />Why does this reasoning make sense?<br /><br />Because govt revenue is a finite source. When you spend money on mosques, you cannot spend that money on roads, schools or hospitals anymore. So even if some of the govt's revenue (for eg. the Petronas portion) was "segregated" or set aside for building mosques - the fact that it was used for building mosques means that that Petronas money can no longer be used for building roads, schools and hospitals. Therefore, non-Muslims AND Muslims are paying for the mosques in the form of fewer roads, schools and hospitals.sean-the-manhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/16015387695941406581noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post-59463158939285379552010-01-08T17:01:47.280+08:002010-01-08T17:01:47.280+08:00Sean,
Stumbled on your site, nice write up. Pity...Sean,<br /><br /> Stumbled on your site, nice write up. Pity your comments are all written by ignorant bn cyber cooties. good rebutall to morky.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post-47169533888765723812009-12-30T16:42:20.813+08:002009-12-30T16:42:20.813+08:00as an immigrant race you should happy to have the ...as an immigrant race you should happy to have the opportunity to live in this country-the origin of malays n bumis.<br /><br />can u name the country dat can give u better living n rights than this?? india? china? singpore?<br />then go there!!!!<br /><br />I DONT THINK SO!!!!!!!!<br /><br /> like malays said 'dah masuk rumah orang nak buat kurang ajar pulak!!' 'tak sedar diri!!!'Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post-46241512674094031112009-12-30T16:36:35.490+08:002009-12-30T16:36:35.490+08:00so i think dat non malays n non bumis shouldnt sta...so i think dat non malays n non bumis shouldnt stay here. go back to your origin country or elsewhere. please reflect yourself before u demanding this and that. dont ever try to claim something dat u cannot give to the others!!!!<br /><br />who is hypocrite here?????Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post-58284302969382888852009-12-27T22:51:35.411+08:002009-12-27T22:51:35.411+08:00Kill us all if you want that all monies..then we d...Kill us all if you want that all monies..then we dont damn f@@king care a bit whether you spend our monies to build countless mos for your ownkind....hypocrite bastard!!!Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post-49737080608653229772009-12-19T14:55:57.865+08:002009-12-19T14:55:57.865+08:001. I said taxes.
Even in terms of govt revenue: P...1. I said taxes.<br /><br />Even in terms of govt revenue: Petronas 44%. Then taxes 56%? Mahathir says 90% of taxes come from non-Malays. That means a full 50% of govt revenue comes from non-Malays.<br /><br />Therefore only 6% comes from Malays ie. Muslims?<br /><br />2. So, are you co-opting Petronas revenues as "Muslim revenue"? I was under the impression that Petronas revenue was for the benefit of all Malaysians, not just Muslims.<br /><br />3. Are you saying that the govt segregates the 44% Petronas money and 6% Malay taxes from the 50% non-Malay taxes... and spends accordingly?<br /><br />Can you prove that?<br /><br />Also, the question then becomes why should the 44% + 6% be spent exclusively on Malays and Muslims, but the 50% is spent on everybody?<br /><br />With your logic of revenue segregation, shouldn't the 50% be spent on all non-Muslim and non-Malays only?<br /><br />In fact...<br /><br />- the Petronas 44% hould be spent on all Malaysians.<br />- the non-Malay/Muslim tax 50% should be spent on non-Malay/Muslims only.<br />- the Malay/Muslim tax 6% should be spent on Malay/Muslims only.<br /><br />Happy?<br /><br />4. The 2nd Star article you quoted Sultan Azlan giving the same argument as Utusan. The rebuttal for the Sultan's argument is therefore the same as for Utusan.<br /><br />Section 3(1) cannot be read in isolation from 3(4), which means 3(1) cannot contravene 11(2).sean-the-manhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/16015387695941406581noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20130311.post-77303676243818568162009-12-19T14:37:33.276+08:002009-12-19T14:37:33.276+08:00How do you know that the money used to build the m...How do you know that the money used to build the mosques are from taxes collected from the non-Muslims?<br /><br />Was there any effort by the government to specifically collect taxes from non-Muslims for the purpose of building mosques?<br /><br />If you are referring to government coffers/treasury which you claim are monies collected from the non-Muslims, kindly do your research to see where does the government gets its' income from.<br /><br />http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2008/11/23/focus/2615044&sec=focus<br /><br />Often, about half of government's revenue come from Petronas. Thus, half of government's money (the so-called "tax-payers money") dont even come from the "taxes" that the rakyat pays.<br /><br />http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/12/19/nation/5336636&sec=nationUnknownhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00906894111479399646noreply@blogger.com