Friday, May 26, 2006

Malaysian school textbooks advocating murder?

This letter was sent to malaysiakini. It details how Pendidikan Islam textbooks are advocating and justifying murder for committing apotasy. Religious prescription aside, is this what we want our children to read in school? And people talk about childish violence in Spongebob Squarepants cartoons being a bad influence... sheesh.

Can anyone confirm this by scanning the pages of the textbook or something?

The text of the letter below:

School textbooks advocating murder
Very Concerned Mother
May 25, 06 4:20pm

I wonder if the present government is aware that violence and murder is being preached through its own curricula and textbooks. This is not an exaggeration. I urge the government to seriously consider if its curriculum for Islamic Education is what it wants to feed young minds.

I was shocked and disturbed to find out that the secondary school syllabus for Islamic Education (Pendidikan Islam) includes learning how to deal with apostates and that one of the prescriptions is to kill them off.

In many widely-used Pendidikan Islam workbooks (which base their texts on the Ministry of Education’s syllabus), imposing a death sentence on apostates is offered as a religious duty. Allow me to extract some of what is written (and the original Malay version for readers to check on context and accuracy).

For example, under the heading ‘Ways of Dealing with Apostates’ (Cara menangani orang murtad), the following precepts are given:

1. Advise and persuade the offender to repent and return to Islam (menasihati dan memintanya supaya bertaubat dan kembali kepada Islam)

2. To impose a death sentence (melaksanakan hukuman bunuh)

The text also has a heading which reads: ‘The death sentence against an apostate who refuses to repent and return to Islam has several virtues’. (Hukuman bunuh terhadap orang murtad yang tidak mahu kembali kepada ajaran Islam mempunyai beberapa hikmah).

Among which are:

1. To show to others at large that Islam is not a religion to be mocked at will (menunjukkan kepada orang ramai bahawa Islam bukanlah agama yang boleh dipersenda dengan sewenang-wenangnya).

2. So that no one will dare to denigrate the Islamic religion (supaya tidak ada orang yang berani memburuk-burukkan agama Islam).

I am not sure now whether the hudud laws passed in Kelantan and Terengganu are now being activated. But for the rest of Malaysia, punishing someone labeled apostate is nothing but a grave act!

We live in a society where everything mouthed by leaders and the authorities (textbooks included) are accepted as the gospel truth. How can we be sure that children fed the above commands will not one day act to fulfill their jihad?

Sadly, it is going to be of the brutal kind and we shall trace the answers behind such a tragedy to our very own government-endorsed textbooks.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...


I am a muslim. The one that you saw in the text book is the gospel truth..

In Islam we also learn such a thing as "your religion is your religion and my religion is my religion". As long as we tolerate between each other than we can live in peace and harmony.

Islamic teachings are to govern the muslims. It is not only for hereafter but to be practiced daily.

I hope you read the whole teaching then you will understand.